{
  "id": "character-arc",
  "title": "Character arcs",
  "aWork": "The Pen",
  "bWork": "The Water Bottle",
  "aAuthor": "Donald Cup",
  "bAuthor": "Marge Magnet",
  "sourceNote": "Fictional teacher-written comparisons: first 5/5 retains the original Chatty Written Example’s argument and structure, with focused accuracy and deconstruction corrections. Other cases are constructed classroom teaching models. Five teaching levels deliberately pair B(i) and B(ii) development; actual Paper 2 assessment can distinguish them.",
  "variations": [
    {
      "id": "character-arc-1",
      "number": 1,
      "label": "Opposed beginnings, convergent endings",
      "description": "The protagonists’ opposed responses to bereavement converge in a comparable loss of purpose.",
      "idea": "Fear of death can damage relationships and prevent purposeful living.",
      "aChoice": "Character arc",
      "bChoice": "Character arc",
      "aGraph": [
        28,
        53,
        79
      ],
      "bGraph": [
        24,
        55,
        78
      ],
      "aMoments": [
        {
          "title": "Opening news of mother’s death",
          "evidence": "Sarah cannot recall when she heard that her mother had died.",
          "deconstruction": "Cup uses the absence of a memorable reaction to construct emotional withdrawal and an already diminished relationship."
        },
        {
          "title": "Concern turns towards her own mortality",
          "evidence": "Sarah moves from disregard of her mother’s death to anxiety about her own future.",
          "deconstruction": "The shift exposes her initial indifference as avoidance when mortality becomes personally relevant."
        },
        {
          "title": "Void of the universe",
          "evidence": "Sarah invokes the “void” of the universe during the final inward reflections.",
          "deconstruction": "Emptiness connotes an absence of purpose and meaningful connection."
        }
      ],
      "bMoments": [
        {
          "title": "Opening news of grandmother’s death",
          "evidence": "Frank immediately and persistently fixates on the death of his grandmother.",
          "deconstruction": "Magnet makes bereavement the dominant object of attention from the outset."
        },
        {
          "title": "Increasing self-directed fixation",
          "evidence": "Frank’s distress develops into repeated concern about his own death.",
          "deconstruction": "Grief becomes increasingly separated from the person mourned and redirects attention towards his own future."
        },
        {
          "title": "Death as the sun",
          "evidence": "Frank compares death to the sun in the final reflections.",
          "deconstruction": "The sun’s centrality makes death an inescapable force around which his thoughts are organised."
        }
      ],
      "exemplar": "Both Donald Cup and Marge Magnet construct their protagonists’ character arcs to explore the destructive effects of the fear of death on individuals. Crucially, while both characters start with opposing responses to bereavement, the writers ultimately show them reaching a comparable conclusion: fearing death causes emotional damage. One striking difference between the constructions is how the characters are introduced. Both receive news of a family member’s death: in The Pen, Sarah learns of her mother’s death, whereas in The Water Bottle, Frank learns of his grandmother’s. Their reactions are almost completely opposed. Sarah shows such disregard for her relationship with her mother that she cannot remember when she received the news; the missing recollection deprives the death of a distinct emotional moment and suggests an already diminished connection. In contrast, Frank fixates on his grandmother’s death in an emotionally wrought manner; Magnet’s emphasis on his persistent distress makes the loss central to how he understands his life. Interestingly, this contrast in the impact of death lessens as both characters develop. Sarah’s initial avoidance gives way to an obsessive concern with her own future death, whereas Frank’s fixation becomes increasingly directed towards his own mortality. In both cases, attention shifts away from the deceased and the relationships that remain, suggesting that apparently opposed responses can produce similar emotional damage. By the end of each text, both characters are completely focused on their future deaths. Cup and Magnet construct stream-of-consciousness-like descriptions and employ cosmic imagery to position their protagonists in relation to mortality: Sarah references the ‘void’ of the universe, whose emptiness suggests an absence of connection or purpose, while Frank reflects on death as the sun, whose centrality makes it a force dominating his thoughts. Although Cup constructs a movement from indifference to fear and Magnet a movement from grief to fixation, both arcs end in extreme ennui. Their different beginnings therefore clarify the same implication: fear of death can displace relationships with the living and make purposeful life seem impossible.",
      "originalFive": "Both Donald Cup and Marge Magnet construct their protagonists’ character arcs to explore the destructive effects of the fear of death on individuals. Crucially, while both characters start with opposing responses to bereavement, the writers ultimately show them reaching a comparable conclusion: fearing death causes emotional damage. One striking difference between the constructions is how the characters are introduced. Both receive news of a family member’s death: in The Pen, Sarah learns of her mother’s death, whereas in The Water Bottle, Frank learns of his grandmother’s. Their reactions are almost completely opposed. Sarah shows such disregard for her relationship with her mother that she cannot remember when she received the news; the missing recollection deprives the death of a distinct emotional moment and suggests an already diminished connection. In contrast, Frank fixates on his grandmother’s death in an emotionally wrought manner; Magnet’s emphasis on his persistent distress makes the loss central to how he understands his life. Interestingly, this contrast in the impact of death lessens as both characters develop. Sarah’s initial avoidance gives way to an obsessive concern with her own future death, whereas Frank’s fixation becomes increasingly directed towards his own mortality. In both cases, attention shifts away from the deceased and the relationships that remain, suggesting that apparently opposed responses can produce similar emotional damage. By the end of each text, both characters are completely focused on their future deaths. Cup and Magnet construct stream-of-consciousness-like descriptions and employ cosmic imagery to position their protagonists in relation to mortality: Sarah references the ‘void’ of the universe, whose emptiness suggests an absence of connection or purpose, while Frank reflects on death as the sun, whose centrality makes it a force dominating his thoughts. Although Cup constructs a movement from indifference to fear and Magnet a movement from grief to fixation, both arcs end in extreme ennui. Their different beginnings therefore clarify the same implication: fear of death can displace relationships with the living and make purposeful life seem impossible.",
      "bands": {
        "1": {
          "level": 1,
          "label": "Basic identification with little analysis or comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "In The Pen, Sarah finds out that her mother has died, although she cannot remember when she received the news. This happens at the beginning and is one of the events that introduces Sarah to the reader. Her reaction is different from what might be expected after a death in the family.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "As the story continues, Sarah begins to think more about death, particularly about her own future. This is a change from the opening because she was not concentrating on death in the same way before. Cup shows this change by giving Sarah more thoughts about her mortality as the story progresses.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "At the end, Sarah refers to the ‘void’ of the universe in her inward reflections. A void is something empty, and it is a word associated with space. This is another example of death being included in the story and of Sarah thinking about what will happen to her.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "These three events occur at different points in The Pen. The character arc begins with the death of Sarah’s mother and finishes with Sarah thinking about her own death. Cup presents the subject of mortality more than once and shows different parts of Sarah’s experience.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "In The Water Bottle, Frank hears that his grandmother has died. He is very distressed by the event, and the death is something he continues to think about.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Later, Frank becomes more concerned about the possibility of his own death. He still thinks about mortality, although he is now thinking about his future as well as what has already happened. This is part of Frank’s development, and the subject continues to feature in several parts of the book.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "In the final reflections, Frank compares death to the sun. The sun is a familiar object that appears in the sky.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Both stories involve a family member dying, followed by the main character thinking about death. The characters do not behave in exactly the same way, and their stories contain different events. The writers show this subject at the beginning, middle and end of the texts.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "In The Pen, Sarah finds out that her mother has died, although she cannot remember when she received the news. This happens at the beginning and is one of the events that introduces Sarah to the reader. Her reaction is different from what might be expected after a death in the family. As the story continues, Sarah begins to think more about death, particularly about her own future. This is a change from the opening because she was not concentrating on death in the same way before. Cup shows this change by giving Sarah more thoughts about her mortality as the story progresses. At the end, Sarah refers to the ‘void’ of the universe in her inward reflections. A void is something empty, and it is a word associated with space. This is another example of death being included in the story and of Sarah thinking about what will happen to her. These three events occur at different points in The Pen. The character arc begins with the death of Sarah’s mother and finishes with Sarah thinking about her own death. Cup presents the subject of mortality more than once and shows different parts of Sarah’s experience. In The Water Bottle, Frank hears that his grandmother has died. He is very distressed by the event, and the death is something he continues to think about. Later, Frank becomes more concerned about the possibility of his own death. He still thinks about mortality, although he is now thinking about his future as well as what has already happened. This is part of Frank’s development, and the subject continues to feature in several parts of the book. In the final reflections, Frank compares death to the sun. The sun is a familiar object that appears in the sky. Both stories involve a family member dying, followed by the main character thinking about death. The characters do not behave in exactly the same way, and their stories contain different events. The writers show this subject at the beginning, middle and end of the texts.",
          "why": "B(i): The writing chiefly recounts or identifies moments. It offers very limited explanation of how authorial choices construct meaning. B(ii): The works are discussed separately, and any relationship is only a broad observation.",
          "nextStep": "Deconstruct one precise detail in each work before explaining the significance of their relationship.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 1/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 1/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "2": {
          "level": 2,
          "label": "Simple effects and surface comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Both The Pen and The Water Bottle examine characters who become concerned about death. Fear of death affects people in different ways, and both authors show this through character arcs.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "In The Pen, Sarah hears that her mother has died, but she cannot remember when the news reached her. This shows that she does not react very strongly, and her response seems strange for someone who has just lost a family member.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank, however, becomes very upset following his grandmother’s death in The Water Bottle. He thinks about his loss often and shows much more emotion than Sarah does. The two protagonists therefore have different reactions at the beginning.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Both writers introduce a death in the family, although the reactions are not the same. This is one of the main differences between the characters.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Later, Sarah begins to worry about her own death even though she was previously unconcerned about her mother's.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank also starts thinking more about his own mortality rather than only his grandmother’s death. His worry continues across the story and becomes an important part of his character. He also experiences a change in what he is concerned about.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Both characters gradually spend more time worrying about their own deaths. The stories therefore become similar in their subject, despite the different reactions with which they began.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Cup ends with Sarah thinking about the ‘void’ of the universe. The word sounds negative and makes the ending seem unhappy. It also makes the reader think about something very large and empty.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Magnet uses the sun when Frank reflects on death near the end. The sun is another large object in the universe and is associated with power, so the image makes death seem very important to him.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Both writers use cosmic imagery at the end of their books and both characters are worried about death. This makes the endings similar, and both show that the protagonists are in difficult situations. Their different beginnings lead to broadly comparable endings.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Both The Pen and The Water Bottle examine characters who become concerned about death. Fear of death affects people in different ways, and both authors show this through character arcs. In The Pen, Sarah hears that her mother has died, but she cannot remember when the news reached her. This shows that she does not react very strongly, and her response seems strange for someone who has just lost a family member. Frank, however, becomes very upset following his grandmother’s death in The Water Bottle. He thinks about his loss often and shows much more emotion than Sarah does. The two protagonists therefore have different reactions at the beginning. Both writers introduce a death in the family, although the reactions are not the same. This is one of the main differences between the characters. Later, Sarah begins to worry about her own death even though she was previously unconcerned about her mother's. Frank also starts thinking more about his own mortality rather than only his grandmother’s death. His worry continues across the story and becomes an important part of his character. He also experiences a change in what he is concerned about. Both characters gradually spend more time worrying about their own deaths. The stories therefore become similar in their subject, despite the different reactions with which they began. Cup ends with Sarah thinking about the ‘void’ of the universe. The word sounds negative and makes the ending seem unhappy. It also makes the reader think about something very large and empty. Magnet uses the sun when Frank reflects on death near the end. The sun is another large object in the universe and is associated with power, so the image makes death seem very important to him. Both writers use cosmic imagery at the end of their books and both characters are worried about death. This makes the endings similar, and both show that the protagonists are in difficult situations. Their different beginnings lead to broadly comparable endings.",
          "why": "B(i): Some choices and effects are recognised, but explanations remain broad or asserted. B(ii): Obvious similarities and differences are identified without explaining why the contrasting constructions matter.",
          "nextStep": "Explain what a specific detail connotes in each work, then compare those implications.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 2/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 2/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "3": {
          "level": 3,
          "label": "Some deconstruction and relevant comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Cup and Magnet use character arcs to explore how a fear of death can affect relationships and purpose. The protagonists begin with different reactions to bereavement, but death becomes increasingly significant in both stories.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah cannot recall when she heard that her mother had died. Cup's use of this missing recollection suggests an emotionally distant relationship, since a major family event has not remained a distinct memory for her.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank immediately fixates on the death of his grandmother. Magnet gives the loss a prominent position in his thoughts, suggesting a more openly distressed response than Sarah's.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The contrast establishes different starting points: Sarah seems indifferent, whereas Frank is preoccupied with his loss. Both responses show that bereavement is important to the development of the protagonists.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah's attitude later changes as she begins to think about her own mortality. The movement from disregard to fear suggests that avoiding another person's death has not prevented her from becoming anxious when death concerns herself.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank also shifts his attention towards his own future death. His continuing grief becomes a more personal anxiety, which suggests that he finds it difficult to move beyond the original loss.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "At this point the protagonists become more alike because both are increasingly concerned with their own futures. Their different emotional reactions are moving towards a comparable subject of anxiety.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "In Sarah's final reflections, the ‘void’ of the universe is associated with emptiness. The image suggests that she now has difficulty finding a sense of purpose.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank compares death to the sun in his final reflections. The image draws attention to the importance of mortality in his thinking, because the sun is so prominent in the sky.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Both endings use images from the universe and show protagonists still thinking about mortality. Cup and Magnet therefore present similar concerns at the end, although the different implications of the ‘void’ and the sun are not explored in much detail. The arcs develop from different opening responses towards a shared preoccupation with death.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Cup and Magnet use character arcs to explore how a fear of death can affect relationships and purpose. The protagonists begin with different reactions to bereavement, but death becomes increasingly significant in both stories. Sarah cannot recall when she heard that her mother had died. Cup's use of this missing recollection suggests an emotionally distant relationship, since a major family event has not remained a distinct memory for her. Frank immediately fixates on the death of his grandmother. Magnet gives the loss a prominent position in his thoughts, suggesting a more openly distressed response than Sarah's. The contrast establishes different starting points: Sarah seems indifferent, whereas Frank is preoccupied with his loss. Both responses show that bereavement is important to the development of the protagonists. Sarah's attitude later changes as she begins to think about her own mortality. The movement from disregard to fear suggests that avoiding another person's death has not prevented her from becoming anxious when death concerns herself. Frank also shifts his attention towards his own future death. His continuing grief becomes a more personal anxiety, which suggests that he finds it difficult to move beyond the original loss. At this point the protagonists become more alike because both are increasingly concerned with their own futures. Their different emotional reactions are moving towards a comparable subject of anxiety. In Sarah's final reflections, the ‘void’ of the universe is associated with emptiness. The image suggests that she now has difficulty finding a sense of purpose. Frank compares death to the sun in his final reflections. The image draws attention to the importance of mortality in his thinking, because the sun is so prominent in the sky. Both endings use images from the universe and show protagonists still thinking about mortality. Cup and Magnet therefore present similar concerns at the end, although the different implications of the ‘void’ and the sun are not explored in much detail. The arcs develop from different opening responses towards a shared preoccupation with death.",
          "why": "B(i): Some individual moments are meaningfully deconstructed, though the analytical precision and coverage are uneven. B(ii): Relevant comparisons begin to explain the shared IDEA, but important relationships remain descriptive or underdeveloped.",
          "nextStep": "Deepen an insufficiently analysed moment and use its specific implication to strengthen a direct comparison.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 3/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 3/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "4": {
          "level": 4,
          "label": "Developed analysis and comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Both writers examine how fear of death can damage relationships and purposeful living.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Cup introduces Sarah through news of her mother’s death, but she cannot remember when she received it.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Making the event difficult for Sarah to locate in memory establishes how little emotional significance she initially allows the relationship.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Magnet begins Frank’s arc with his immediate distress following his grandmother’s death.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "His repeated fixation makes bereavement a persistent organising concern, so that the death dominates his understanding of events from the beginning.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The opposite opening reactions establish two kinds of withdrawal: Sarah gives the death little space in her thoughts, while Frank makes it central to his life.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "As The Pen develops, Sarah’s earlier disregard for her mother’s death becomes concern about her own mortality.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her changed attention reveals that her apparent indifference was not a stable response to the fact of death.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "In The Water Bottle, Frank’s persistent grief increasingly becomes anxiety about his own future death.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Magnet redirects his attention from the grandmother who has died to the mortality he fears for himself, narrowing his relationships with the living.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The later turns towards their own mortality reveal a substantial similarity in where both arcs are heading, despite the disparity between avoidance and persistent grief.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Cup’s final stream-of-consciousness-like description includes Sarah’s reference to the ‘void’ of the universe.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "The image suggests emptiness and an absence of connection, making her loss of purpose evident at the end of the arc.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "In the final inward reflections, Frank compares death to the sun.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "The sun’s central position suggests a force governing what surrounds it, so that mortality has come to organise his thoughts and restrict his purpose.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Both final images suggest a loss of direction, linking the different arcs through their comparable emotional decline.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Sarah’s lack of memory becomes particularly significant once her concern turns towards her own future.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Frank’s recollection similarly becomes less connected with his grandmother as the fear becomes more self-directed.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Both writers examine how fear of death can damage relationships and purposeful living. Cup introduces Sarah through news of her mother’s death, but she cannot remember when she received it. Making the event difficult for Sarah to locate in memory establishes how little emotional significance she initially allows the relationship. Magnet begins Frank’s arc with his immediate distress following his grandmother’s death. His repeated fixation makes bereavement a persistent organising concern, so that the death dominates his understanding of events from the beginning. The opposite opening reactions establish two kinds of withdrawal: Sarah gives the death little space in her thoughts, while Frank makes it central to his life. As The Pen develops, Sarah’s earlier disregard for her mother’s death becomes concern about her own mortality. Her changed attention reveals that her apparent indifference was not a stable response to the fact of death. In The Water Bottle, Frank’s persistent grief increasingly becomes anxiety about his own future death. Magnet redirects his attention from the grandmother who has died to the mortality he fears for himself, narrowing his relationships with the living. The later turns towards their own mortality reveal a substantial similarity in where both arcs are heading, despite the disparity between avoidance and persistent grief. Cup’s final stream-of-consciousness-like description includes Sarah’s reference to the ‘void’ of the universe. The image suggests emptiness and an absence of connection, making her loss of purpose evident at the end of the arc. In the final inward reflections, Frank compares death to the sun. The sun’s central position suggests a force governing what surrounds it, so that mortality has come to organise his thoughts and restrict his purpose. Both final images suggest a loss of direction, linking the different arcs through their comparable emotional decline. Sarah’s lack of memory becomes particularly significant once her concern turns towards her own future. Frank’s recollection similarly becomes less connected with his grandmother as the fear becomes more self-directed.",
          "why": "B(i): Most selected moments receive relevant, specific deconstruction, although not every implication is equally developed. B(ii): The work makes substantive comparisons across the wider construction, with occasional loss of precision or sustained synthesis.",
          "nextStep": "Refine the least fully explained paired moment and its relationship to the governing IDEA.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 4/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 4/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "5": {
          "level": 5,
          "label": "Sustained comparative deconstruction",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Both Donald Cup and Marge Magnet construct their protagonists’ character arcs to explore the destructive effects of the fear of death on individuals.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Crucially, while both characters start with opposing responses to bereavement, the writers ultimately show them reaching a comparable conclusion: fearing death causes emotional damage.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "while",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "One striking difference between the constructions is how the characters are introduced.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Both receive news of a family member’s death: in The Pen, Sarah learns of her mother’s death, whereas in The Water Bottle, Frank learns of his grandmother’s.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "whereas",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Their reactions are almost completely opposed.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows such disregard for her relationship with her mother that she cannot remember when she received the news; the missing recollection deprives the death of a distinct emotional moment and suggests an already diminished connection.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "In contrast, Frank fixates on his grandmother’s death in an emotionally wrought manner; Magnet’s emphasis on his persistent distress makes the loss central to how he understands his life.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "In contrast",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Interestingly, this contrast in the impact of death lessens as both characters develop.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Sarah’s initial avoidance gives way to an obsessive concern with her own future death, whereas Frank’s fixation becomes increasingly directed towards his own mortality.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "whereas",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "In both cases, attention shifts away from the deceased and the relationships that remain, suggesting that apparently opposed responses can produce similar emotional damage.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "By the end of each text, both characters are completely focused on their future deaths.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Cup and Magnet construct stream-of-consciousness-like descriptions and employ cosmic imagery to position their protagonists in relation to mortality: Sarah references the ‘void’ of the universe, whose emptiness suggests an absence of connection or purpose, while Frank reflects on death as the sun, whose centrality makes it a force dominating his thoughts.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "while",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Although Cup constructs a movement from indifference to fear and Magnet a movement from grief to fixation, both arcs end in extreme ennui.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "Although",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Their different beginnings therefore clarify the same implication: fear of death can displace relationships with the living and make purposeful life seem impossible.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Both Donald Cup and Marge Magnet construct their protagonists’ character arcs to explore the destructive effects of the fear of death on individuals. Crucially, while both characters start with opposing responses to bereavement, the writers ultimately show them reaching a comparable conclusion: fearing death causes emotional damage. One striking difference between the constructions is how the characters are introduced. Both receive news of a family member’s death: in The Pen, Sarah learns of her mother’s death, whereas in The Water Bottle, Frank learns of his grandmother’s. Their reactions are almost completely opposed. Sarah shows such disregard for her relationship with her mother that she cannot remember when she received the news; the missing recollection deprives the death of a distinct emotional moment and suggests an already diminished connection. In contrast, Frank fixates on his grandmother’s death in an emotionally wrought manner; Magnet’s emphasis on his persistent distress makes the loss central to how he understands his life. Interestingly, this contrast in the impact of death lessens as both characters develop. Sarah’s initial avoidance gives way to an obsessive concern with her own future death, whereas Frank’s fixation becomes increasingly directed towards his own mortality. In both cases, attention shifts away from the deceased and the relationships that remain, suggesting that apparently opposed responses can produce similar emotional damage. By the end of each text, both characters are completely focused on their future deaths. Cup and Magnet construct stream-of-consciousness-like descriptions and employ cosmic imagery to position their protagonists in relation to mortality: Sarah references the ‘void’ of the universe, whose emptiness suggests an absence of connection or purpose, while Frank reflects on death as the sun, whose centrality makes it a force dominating his thoughts. Although Cup constructs a movement from indifference to fear and Magnet a movement from grief to fixation, both arcs end in extreme ennui. Their different beginnings therefore clarify the same implication: fear of death can displace relationships with the living and make purposeful life seem impossible.",
          "why": "B(i): Specific details of the authorial constructions are consistently deconstructed in relation to the IDEA. B(ii): Those implications are compared directly and develop a sustained argument across the works. Other valid comparative arrangements may achieve the same quality.",
          "nextStep": "Extend or refine only if a genuine contextual or analytical limitation remains; do not require a revision merely for its own sake.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 5/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "teacher-original-minimally-corrected",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 5/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        }
      },
      "teacherSource": "Teacher’s original Chatty Written Example: attribution, placeholders and focused analytical precision corrected; structure retained."
    },
    {
      "id": "character-arc-2",
      "number": 2,
      "label": "Different constructions",
      "description": "The two writers use different developments of the same broad choice.",
      "idea": "Grief can develop into persistent anxiety whether it is initially suppressed or openly expressed.",
      "aChoice": "Character arc",
      "bChoice": "Character arc",
      "aGraph": [
        68,
        48,
        33
      ],
      "bGraph": [
        35,
        49,
        67
      ],
      "aMoments": [
        {
          "title": "News of her mother’s death",
          "evidence": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news.",
          "deconstruction": "Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother. This opening establishes a distinct way of introducing the conceptual concern."
        },
        {
          "title": "Sarah begins considering her own death",
          "evidence": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future.",
          "deconstruction": "The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality. The distinctive construction clarifies why the same concern develops differently. The middle stage develops the difference in each work’s construction."
        },
        {
          "title": "Final inward fixation",
          "evidence": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose.",
          "deconstruction": "Her final condition demonstrates the personal consequences of unmanaged fear. The final stage establishes consequences that need to be compared, even where the experiences differ."
        }
      ],
      "bMoments": [
        {
          "title": "News of his grandmother’s death",
          "evidence": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss.",
          "deconstruction": "Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. This opening establishes a distinct way of introducing the conceptual concern."
        },
        {
          "title": "Increasing preoccupation",
          "evidence": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him.",
          "deconstruction": "His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others. The distinctive construction clarifies why the same concern develops differently. The middle stage develops the difference in each work’s construction."
        },
        {
          "title": "Final self-destructive fixation",
          "evidence": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction.",
          "deconstruction": "The similar ending links his fixation to Sarah’s different initial avoidance. The final stage establishes consequences that need to be compared, even where the experiences differ."
        }
      ],
      "exemplar": "The contrasting openings of Sarah’s and Frank’s arcs establish how differently the protagonists respond to a death in the family. Cup introduces Sarah through her inability even to place the moment she learned of her mother’s death, suggesting that she has distanced herself from the loss. Magnet’s Frank, who repeatedly returns to his grandmother’s death, is unable to distance himself in the same way. Sarah’s inability to place the news in her memory makes indifference the starting point of her arc, whereas Frank’s returning thoughts give grief immediate control of his attention. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother, while Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. Their subsequent developments are also different: Sarah begins to acknowledge mortality only when the prospect of her own death concerns her, whereas Frank’s distress gradually extends from the original bereavement to his wider future. Sarah’s later fear for herself exposes the limitations of avoidance; Frank’s increasing preoccupation demonstrates how openly expressed grief can become similarly restrictive. Both characters eventually become preoccupied with death, but their earlier decisions remain significant. Cup shows how avoidance delays recognition of grief, while Magnet shows the consequences of allowing the initial loss to determine a character’s later conduct. The later change also reinterprets the protagonists’ beginnings: Sarah’s early failure to remember the announcement is no longer evidence of immunity, and Frank’s persistent distress has become a narrowing preoccupation. The convergence matters because the opposing ways of registering bereavement now lead the protagonists towards a similarly restrictive concern with their own deaths.",
      "originalFive": "The contrasting openings of Sarah’s and Frank’s arcs establish how differently the protagonists respond to a death in the family. Cup introduces Sarah through her inability even to place the moment she learned of her mother’s death, suggesting that she has distanced herself from the loss. Magnet’s Frank, who repeatedly returns to his grandmother’s death, is unable to distance himself in the same way. Sarah’s inability to place the news in her memory makes indifference the starting point of her arc, whereas Frank’s returning thoughts give grief immediate control of his attention. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother, while Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. Their subsequent developments are also different: Sarah begins to acknowledge mortality only when the prospect of her own death concerns her, whereas Frank’s distress gradually extends from the original bereavement to his wider future. Sarah’s later fear for herself exposes the limitations of avoidance; Frank’s increasing preoccupation demonstrates how openly expressed grief can become similarly restrictive. Both characters eventually become preoccupied with death, but their earlier decisions remain significant. Cup shows how avoidance delays recognition of grief, while Magnet shows the consequences of allowing the initial loss to determine a character’s later conduct. The later change also reinterprets the protagonists’ beginnings: Sarah’s early failure to remember the announcement is no longer evidence of immunity, and Frank’s persistent distress has become a narrowing preoccupation. The convergence matters because the opposing ways of registering bereavement now lead the protagonists towards a similarly restrictive concern with their own deaths.",
      "bands": {
        "1": {
          "level": 1,
          "label": "Basic identification with little analysis or comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Donald Cup uses character arc in The Pen.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. The event introduces how the central character reacts at this stage of the story. The death is one of the things that happens at the start.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. This is a later development for the character, who now responds differently from before. It is part of what happens to the character over time.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. The final description shows the character at the end of the work. It follows the earlier developments and concludes the character’s experience.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Marge Magnet uses character arc in The Water Bottle. This work deals with a similar general subject through another sequence of events.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. The author introduces another character in a situation involving death. The story begins by showing the character’s reaction to the news.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. This is a further stage in the character’s story, after the original event. The reader sees how the situation continues to change.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The last scene describes what the character is thinking about near the end. It comes after the other events in the character’s story.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The Pen and The Water Bottle both deal with a related subject. The events in the two works are different, but in both cases the writers return to it throughout the stories.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup uses character arc in The Pen. Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. The event introduces how the central character reacts at this stage of the story. The death is one of the things that happens at the start. Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. This is a later development for the character, who now responds differently from before. It is part of what happens to the character over time. Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. The final description shows the character at the end of the work. It follows the earlier developments and concludes the character’s experience. Marge Magnet uses character arc in The Water Bottle. This work deals with a similar general subject through another sequence of events. Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. The author introduces another character in a situation involving death. The story begins by showing the character’s reaction to the news. Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. This is a further stage in the character’s story, after the original event. The reader sees how the situation continues to change. Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The last scene describes what the character is thinking about near the end. It comes after the other events in the character’s story. The Pen and The Water Bottle both deal with a related subject. The events in the two works are different, but in both cases the writers return to it throughout the stories.",
          "why": "B(i): The writing chiefly recounts or identifies moments. It offers very limited explanation of how authorial choices construct meaning. B(ii): The works are discussed separately, and any relationship is only a broad observation.",
          "nextStep": "Deconstruct one precise detail in each work before explaining the significance of their relationship.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 1/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 1/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "2": {
          "level": 2,
          "label": "Simple effects and surface comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both explore a similar concern in The Pen and The Water Bottle. Grief can develop into persistent anxiety whether it is initially suppressed or openly expressed.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. This shows the character’s reaction to the event. This is introduced near the beginning.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. This shows the character’s reaction to the event.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The opening moments involve News of her mother’s death and News of his grandmother’s death. They are different, but both introduce the subject of the two works.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The reaction changes during the story. This follows the earlier situation.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. The reaction changes during the story. The events develop further after this point.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The two later moments also concern the same issue. The authors choose different events, and both move their stories on from the beginning.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. The ending continues to show the character’s feelings.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The ending continues to show the character’s feelings.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "These endings are alike because they both return to the central concern. The descriptions and situations are different in each text.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The choices in The Pen and The Water Bottle are similar in a general way because both writers address this issue. Each story has moments at the beginning, middle and end that deal with it.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both explore a similar concern in The Pen and The Water Bottle. Grief can develop into persistent anxiety whether it is initially suppressed or openly expressed. Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. This shows the character’s reaction to the event. This is introduced near the beginning. Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. This shows the character’s reaction to the event. The opening moments involve News of her mother’s death and News of his grandmother’s death. They are different, but both introduce the subject of the two works. Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The reaction changes during the story. This follows the earlier situation. Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. The reaction changes during the story. The events develop further after this point. The two later moments also concern the same issue. The authors choose different events, and both move their stories on from the beginning. Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. The ending continues to show the character’s feelings. Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The ending continues to show the character’s feelings. These endings are alike because they both return to the central concern. The descriptions and situations are different in each text. The choices in The Pen and The Water Bottle are similar in a general way because both writers address this issue. Each story has moments at the beginning, middle and end that deal with it.",
          "why": "B(i): Some choices and effects are recognised, but explanations remain broad or asserted. B(ii): Obvious similarities and differences are identified without explaining why the contrasting constructions matter.",
          "nextStep": "Explain what a specific detail connotes in each work, then compare those implications.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 2/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 2/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "3": {
          "level": 3,
          "label": "Some deconstruction and relevant comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet develop a related concern across The Pen and The Water Bottle. Grief can develop into persistent anxiety whether it is initially suppressed or openly expressed.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The first moments establish a related concern, but the initial situations are different. This contrast gives the two works different starting points for the same topic.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The later events continue the concern in both works.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. This concluding detail returns to the problem developed earlier in the work.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The final scene or image similarly returns attention to that problem.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The final moments return to the concern raised earlier, and both give further evidence of its importance. The endings can be connected to each other at the level of the characters’ or situations’ outcomes.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Together, these moments show a developing relationship between the works. The first two pairs provide some explanation of meaning, while the final situations link the texts more generally.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet develop a related concern across The Pen and The Water Bottle. Grief can develop into persistent anxiety whether it is initially suppressed or openly expressed. Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother. Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. The first moments establish a related concern, but the initial situations are different. This contrast gives the two works different starting points for the same topic. Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality. Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others. The later events continue the concern in both works. Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. This concluding detail returns to the problem developed earlier in the work. Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The final scene or image similarly returns attention to that problem. The final moments return to the concern raised earlier, and both give further evidence of its importance. The endings can be connected to each other at the level of the characters’ or situations’ outcomes. Together, these moments show a developing relationship between the works. The first two pairs provide some explanation of meaning, while the final situations link the texts more generally.",
          "why": "B(i): Some individual moments are meaningfully deconstructed, though the analytical precision and coverage are uneven. B(ii): Relevant comparisons begin to explain the shared IDEA, but important relationships remain descriptive or underdeveloped.",
          "nextStep": "Deepen an insufficiently analysed moment and use its specific implication to strengthen a direct comparison.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 3/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 3/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "4": {
          "level": 4,
          "label": "Developed analysis and comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both examine the idea that grief can develop into persistent anxiety whether it is initially suppressed or openly expressed, constructing distinct developments across their works.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The contrast between news of her mother’s death and news of his grandmother’s death establishes distinct starting points for the comparison.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The middle pair qualifies those openings, showing how the choices continue to affect what the characters understand and whether their responses become more restrictive.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. Her final condition demonstrates the personal consequences of unmanaged fear.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The similar ending links his fixation to Sarah’s different initial avoidance.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The outcomes bring the shared IDEA into focus, and each ending gains meaning from the earlier moments; the comparison still needs to explain more precisely why the final authorial decisions differ.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both examine the idea that grief can develop into persistent anxiety whether it is initially suppressed or openly expressed, constructing distinct developments across their works. Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother. Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. The contrast between news of her mother’s death and news of his grandmother’s death establishes distinct starting points for the comparison. Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality. Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others. The middle pair qualifies those openings, showing how the choices continue to affect what the characters understand and whether their responses become more restrictive. Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. Her final condition demonstrates the personal consequences of unmanaged fear. Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The similar ending links his fixation to Sarah’s different initial avoidance. The outcomes bring the shared IDEA into focus, and each ending gains meaning from the earlier moments; the comparison still needs to explain more precisely why the final authorial decisions differ.",
          "why": "B(i): Most selected moments receive relevant, specific deconstruction, although not every implication is equally developed. B(ii): The work makes substantive comparisons across the wider construction, with occasional loss of precision or sustained synthesis.",
          "nextStep": "Refine the least fully explained paired moment and its relationship to the governing IDEA.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 4/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 4/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "5": {
          "level": 5,
          "label": "Sustained comparative deconstruction",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The contrasting openings of Sarah’s and Frank’s arcs establish how differently the protagonists respond to a death in the family.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Cup introduces Sarah through her inability even to place the moment she learned of her mother’s death, suggesting that she has distanced herself from the loss.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Magnet’s Frank, who repeatedly returns to his grandmother’s death, is unable to distance himself in the same way.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Sarah’s inability to place the news in her memory makes indifference the starting point of her arc, whereas Frank’s returning thoughts give grief immediate control of his attention.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "whereas",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother, while Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "while",
                  "kind": "idea"
                },
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Their subsequent developments are also different: Sarah begins to acknowledge mortality only when the prospect of her own death concerns her, whereas Frank’s distress gradually extends from the original bereavement to his wider future.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "whereas",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Sarah’s later fear for herself exposes the limitations of avoidance; Frank’s increasing preoccupation demonstrates how openly expressed grief can become similarly restrictive.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Both characters eventually become preoccupied with death, but their earlier decisions remain significant.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Cup shows how avoidance delays recognition of grief, while Magnet shows the consequences of allowing the initial loss to determine a character’s later conduct.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "while",
                  "kind": "idea"
                },
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The later change also reinterprets the protagonists’ beginnings: Sarah’s early failure to remember the announcement is no longer evidence of immunity, and Frank’s persistent distress has become a narrowing preoccupation.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The convergence matters because the opposing ways of registering bereavement now lead the protagonists towards a similarly restrictive concern with their own deaths.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "The contrasting openings of Sarah’s and Frank’s arcs establish how differently the protagonists respond to a death in the family. Cup introduces Sarah through her inability even to place the moment she learned of her mother’s death, suggesting that she has distanced herself from the loss. Magnet’s Frank, who repeatedly returns to his grandmother’s death, is unable to distance himself in the same way. Sarah’s inability to place the news in her memory makes indifference the starting point of her arc, whereas Frank’s returning thoughts give grief immediate control of his attention. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother, while Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. Their subsequent developments are also different: Sarah begins to acknowledge mortality only when the prospect of her own death concerns her, whereas Frank’s distress gradually extends from the original bereavement to his wider future. Sarah’s later fear for herself exposes the limitations of avoidance; Frank’s increasing preoccupation demonstrates how openly expressed grief can become similarly restrictive. Both characters eventually become preoccupied with death, but their earlier decisions remain significant. Cup shows how avoidance delays recognition of grief, while Magnet shows the consequences of allowing the initial loss to determine a character’s later conduct. The later change also reinterprets the protagonists’ beginnings: Sarah’s early failure to remember the announcement is no longer evidence of immunity, and Frank’s persistent distress has become a narrowing preoccupation. The convergence matters because the opposing ways of registering bereavement now lead the protagonists towards a similarly restrictive concern with their own deaths.",
          "why": "B(i): Specific details of the authorial constructions are consistently deconstructed in relation to the IDEA. B(ii): Those implications are compared directly and develop a sustained argument across the works. Other valid comparative arrangements may achieve the same quality.",
          "nextStep": "Extend or refine only if a genuine contextual or analytical limitation remains; do not require a revision merely for its own sake.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 5/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "fictional-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 5/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        }
      },
      "teacherSource": "Scenario-specific constructed variation"
    },
    {
      "id": "character-arc-3",
      "number": 3,
      "label": "Similarities and differences",
      "description": "The choices correspond at some moments and differ at others.",
      "idea": "Avoiding grief and becoming consumed by it can both diminish an individual’s sense of purpose.",
      "aChoice": "Character arc",
      "bChoice": "Character arc",
      "aGraph": [
        36,
        64,
        45
      ],
      "bGraph": [
        45,
        42,
        88
      ],
      "aMoments": [
        {
          "title": "News of her mother’s death",
          "evidence": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news.",
          "deconstruction": "Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother. This opening establishes a shared concern that the two writers will develop differently."
        },
        {
          "title": "Sarah begins considering her own death",
          "evidence": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future.",
          "deconstruction": "The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality. This change complicates the initial similarity between the works. The middle stage makes the later divergence or convergence visible."
        },
        {
          "title": "Final inward fixation",
          "evidence": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose.",
          "deconstruction": "Her final condition demonstrates the personal consequences of unmanaged fear. The ending can qualify the initial resemblance through its different implications."
        }
      ],
      "bMoments": [
        {
          "title": "News of his grandmother’s death",
          "evidence": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss.",
          "deconstruction": "Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. This opening establishes a shared concern that the two writers will develop differently."
        },
        {
          "title": "Increasing preoccupation",
          "evidence": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him.",
          "deconstruction": "His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others. This change complicates the initial similarity between the works. The middle stage makes the later divergence or convergence visible."
        },
        {
          "title": "Final self-destructive fixation",
          "evidence": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction.",
          "deconstruction": "The similar ending links his fixation to Sarah’s different initial avoidance. The ending can qualify the initial resemblance through its different implications."
        }
      ],
      "exemplar": "Cup and Magnet establish different initial responses to bereavement, then give Sarah and Frank increasingly similar concerns as their narratives progress. Sarah’s indifference to news of her mother’s death initially separates her from Frank, whose grandmother’s death occupies his thoughts from the beginning. Later, Sarah begins to focus on her own possible death, while Frank’s established fixation becomes more damaging to his relationships. Sarah’s inability to place the news in her memory makes indifference the starting point of her arc, whereas Frank’s returning thoughts give grief immediate control of his attention. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother, while Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. The contrast between Sarah’s late recognition and Frank’s immediate distress matters because neither response gives the character a way of living alongside loss. Sarah’s later fear for herself exposes the limitations of avoidance; Frank’s increasing preoccupation demonstrates how openly expressed grief can become similarly restrictive. By the concluding moments, both are increasingly unable to pursue ordinary interests or relationships. Their movement from contrasting reactions to a similar condition supports the idea that emotional avoidance and prolonged fixation can each prevent a person from dealing with grief. The later change also reinterprets the protagonists’ beginnings: Sarah’s early failure to remember the announcement is no longer evidence of immunity, and Frank’s persistent distress has become a narrowing preoccupation. The convergence matters because the opposing ways of registering bereavement now lead the protagonists towards a similarly restrictive concern with their own deaths.",
      "originalFive": "Cup and Magnet establish different initial responses to bereavement, then give Sarah and Frank increasingly similar concerns as their narratives progress. Sarah’s indifference to news of her mother’s death initially separates her from Frank, whose grandmother’s death occupies his thoughts from the beginning. Later, Sarah begins to focus on her own possible death, while Frank’s established fixation becomes more damaging to his relationships. Sarah’s inability to place the news in her memory makes indifference the starting point of her arc, whereas Frank’s returning thoughts give grief immediate control of his attention. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother, while Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. The contrast between Sarah’s late recognition and Frank’s immediate distress matters because neither response gives the character a way of living alongside loss. Sarah’s later fear for herself exposes the limitations of avoidance; Frank’s increasing preoccupation demonstrates how openly expressed grief can become similarly restrictive. By the concluding moments, both are increasingly unable to pursue ordinary interests or relationships. Their movement from contrasting reactions to a similar condition supports the idea that emotional avoidance and prolonged fixation can each prevent a person from dealing with grief. The later change also reinterprets the protagonists’ beginnings: Sarah’s early failure to remember the announcement is no longer evidence of immunity, and Frank’s persistent distress has become a narrowing preoccupation. The convergence matters because the opposing ways of registering bereavement now lead the protagonists towards a similarly restrictive concern with their own deaths.",
      "bands": {
        "1": {
          "level": 1,
          "label": "Basic identification with little analysis or comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Donald Cup uses character arc in The Pen.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. The event introduces how the central character reacts at this stage of the story. The death is one of the things that happens at the start.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. This is a later development for the character, who now responds differently from before. It is part of what happens to the character over time.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. The final description shows the character at the end of the work. It follows the earlier developments and concludes the character’s experience.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Marge Magnet uses character arc in The Water Bottle.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. The author introduces another character in a situation involving death. The story begins by showing the character’s reaction to the news.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. This is a further stage in the character’s story, after the original event. The reader sees how the situation continues to change.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The last scene describes what the character is thinking about near the end. It comes after the other events in the character’s story.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The Pen and The Water Bottle both deal with a related subject. The events in the two works are different, but in both cases the writers return to it throughout the stories.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup uses character arc in The Pen. Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. The event introduces how the central character reacts at this stage of the story. The death is one of the things that happens at the start. Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. This is a later development for the character, who now responds differently from before. It is part of what happens to the character over time. Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. The final description shows the character at the end of the work. It follows the earlier developments and concludes the character’s experience. Marge Magnet uses character arc in The Water Bottle. Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. The author introduces another character in a situation involving death. The story begins by showing the character’s reaction to the news. Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. This is a further stage in the character’s story, after the original event. The reader sees how the situation continues to change. Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The last scene describes what the character is thinking about near the end. It comes after the other events in the character’s story. The Pen and The Water Bottle both deal with a related subject. The events in the two works are different, but in both cases the writers return to it throughout the stories.",
          "why": "B(i): The writing chiefly recounts or identifies moments. It offers very limited explanation of how authorial choices construct meaning. B(ii): The works are discussed separately, and any relationship is only a broad observation.",
          "nextStep": "Deconstruct one precise detail in each work before explaining the significance of their relationship.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 1/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 1/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "2": {
          "level": 2,
          "label": "Simple effects and surface comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both explore a similar concern in The Pen and The Water Bottle. Avoiding grief and becoming consumed by it can both diminish an individual’s sense of purpose.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. This shows the character’s reaction to the event. This is introduced near the beginning.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The opening moments involve News of her mother’s death and News of his grandmother’s death. They are different, but both introduce the subject of the two works.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The reaction changes during the story. This follows the earlier situation.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. The reaction changes during the story. The events develop further after this point.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The two later moments also concern the same issue. The authors choose different events, and both move their stories on from the beginning.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. The ending continues to show the character’s feelings.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The ending continues to show the character’s feelings.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "These endings are alike because they both return to the central concern. The descriptions and situations are different in each text.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The choices in The Pen and The Water Bottle are similar in a general way because both writers address this issue. Each story has moments at the beginning, middle and end that deal with it.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both explore a similar concern in The Pen and The Water Bottle. Avoiding grief and becoming consumed by it can both diminish an individual’s sense of purpose. Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. This shows the character’s reaction to the event. This is introduced near the beginning. Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. The opening moments involve News of her mother’s death and News of his grandmother’s death. They are different, but both introduce the subject of the two works. Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The reaction changes during the story. This follows the earlier situation. Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. The reaction changes during the story. The events develop further after this point. The two later moments also concern the same issue. The authors choose different events, and both move their stories on from the beginning. Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. The ending continues to show the character’s feelings. Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The ending continues to show the character’s feelings. These endings are alike because they both return to the central concern. The descriptions and situations are different in each text. The choices in The Pen and The Water Bottle are similar in a general way because both writers address this issue. Each story has moments at the beginning, middle and end that deal with it.",
          "why": "B(i): Some choices and effects are recognised, but explanations remain broad or asserted. B(ii): Obvious similarities and differences are identified without explaining why the contrasting constructions matter.",
          "nextStep": "Explain what a specific detail connotes in each work, then compare those implications.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 2/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 2/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "3": {
          "level": 3,
          "label": "Some deconstruction and relevant comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet develop a related concern across The Pen and The Water Bottle. Avoiding grief and becoming consumed by it can both diminish an individual’s sense of purpose.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The first moments establish a related concern, but the initial situations are different. This contrast gives the two works different starting points for the same topic.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The later events continue the concern in both works.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. This concluding detail returns to the problem developed earlier in the work.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The final scene or image similarly returns attention to that problem.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The final moments return to the concern raised earlier, and both give further evidence of its importance. The endings can be connected to each other at the level of the characters’ or situations’ outcomes.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Together, these moments show a developing relationship between the works.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet develop a related concern across The Pen and The Water Bottle. Avoiding grief and becoming consumed by it can both diminish an individual’s sense of purpose. Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother. Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. The first moments establish a related concern, but the initial situations are different. This contrast gives the two works different starting points for the same topic. Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality. Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others. The later events continue the concern in both works. Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. This concluding detail returns to the problem developed earlier in the work. Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The final scene or image similarly returns attention to that problem. The final moments return to the concern raised earlier, and both give further evidence of its importance. The endings can be connected to each other at the level of the characters’ or situations’ outcomes. Together, these moments show a developing relationship between the works.",
          "why": "B(i): Some individual moments are meaningfully deconstructed, though the analytical precision and coverage are uneven. B(ii): Relevant comparisons begin to explain the shared IDEA, but important relationships remain descriptive or underdeveloped.",
          "nextStep": "Deepen an insufficiently analysed moment and use its specific implication to strengthen a direct comparison.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 3/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 3/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "4": {
          "level": 4,
          "label": "Developed analysis and comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both examine the idea that avoiding grief and becoming consumed by it can both diminish an individual’s sense of purpose, constructing distinct developments across their works.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The contrast between news of her mother’s death and news of his grandmother’s death establishes distinct starting points for the comparison.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The middle pair qualifies those openings, showing how the choices continue to affect what the characters understand and whether their responses become more restrictive.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. Her final condition demonstrates the personal consequences of unmanaged fear.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The similar ending links his fixation to Sarah’s different initial avoidance.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The outcomes bring the shared IDEA into focus, and each ending gains meaning from the earlier moments; the comparison still needs to explain more precisely why the final authorial decisions differ.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both examine the idea that avoiding grief and becoming consumed by it can both diminish an individual’s sense of purpose, constructing distinct developments across their works. Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother. Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. The contrast between news of her mother’s death and news of his grandmother’s death establishes distinct starting points for the comparison. Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality. Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others. The middle pair qualifies those openings, showing how the choices continue to affect what the characters understand and whether their responses become more restrictive. Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. Her final condition demonstrates the personal consequences of unmanaged fear. Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The similar ending links his fixation to Sarah’s different initial avoidance. The outcomes bring the shared IDEA into focus, and each ending gains meaning from the earlier moments; the comparison still needs to explain more precisely why the final authorial decisions differ.",
          "why": "B(i): Most selected moments receive relevant, specific deconstruction, although not every implication is equally developed. B(ii): The work makes substantive comparisons across the wider construction, with occasional loss of precision or sustained synthesis.",
          "nextStep": "Refine the least fully explained paired moment and its relationship to the governing IDEA.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 4/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 4/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "5": {
          "level": 5,
          "label": "Sustained comparative deconstruction",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Cup and Magnet establish different initial responses to bereavement, then give Sarah and Frank increasingly similar concerns as their narratives progress.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Sarah’s indifference to news of her mother’s death initially separates her from Frank, whose grandmother’s death occupies his thoughts from the beginning.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Later, Sarah begins to focus on her own possible death, while Frank’s established fixation becomes more damaging to his relationships.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "while",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Sarah’s inability to place the news in her memory makes indifference the starting point of her arc, whereas Frank’s returning thoughts give grief immediate control of his attention.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "whereas",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother, while Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "while",
                  "kind": "idea"
                },
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The contrast between Sarah’s late recognition and Frank’s immediate distress matters because neither response gives the character a way of living alongside loss.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Sarah’s later fear for herself exposes the limitations of avoidance; Frank’s increasing preoccupation demonstrates how openly expressed grief can become similarly restrictive.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "By the concluding moments, both are increasingly unable to pursue ordinary interests or relationships.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Their movement from contrasting reactions to a similar condition supports the idea that emotional avoidance and prolonged fixation can each prevent a person from dealing with grief.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The later change also reinterprets the protagonists’ beginnings: Sarah’s early failure to remember the announcement is no longer evidence of immunity, and Frank’s persistent distress has become a narrowing preoccupation.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The convergence matters because the opposing ways of registering bereavement now lead the protagonists towards a similarly restrictive concern with their own deaths.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Cup and Magnet establish different initial responses to bereavement, then give Sarah and Frank increasingly similar concerns as their narratives progress. Sarah’s indifference to news of her mother’s death initially separates her from Frank, whose grandmother’s death occupies his thoughts from the beginning. Later, Sarah begins to focus on her own possible death, while Frank’s established fixation becomes more damaging to his relationships. Sarah’s inability to place the news in her memory makes indifference the starting point of her arc, whereas Frank’s returning thoughts give grief immediate control of his attention. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother, while Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. The contrast between Sarah’s late recognition and Frank’s immediate distress matters because neither response gives the character a way of living alongside loss. Sarah’s later fear for herself exposes the limitations of avoidance; Frank’s increasing preoccupation demonstrates how openly expressed grief can become similarly restrictive. By the concluding moments, both are increasingly unable to pursue ordinary interests or relationships. Their movement from contrasting reactions to a similar condition supports the idea that emotional avoidance and prolonged fixation can each prevent a person from dealing with grief. The later change also reinterprets the protagonists’ beginnings: Sarah’s early failure to remember the announcement is no longer evidence of immunity, and Frank’s persistent distress has become a narrowing preoccupation. The convergence matters because the opposing ways of registering bereavement now lead the protagonists towards a similarly restrictive concern with their own deaths.",
          "why": "B(i): Specific details of the authorial constructions are consistently deconstructed in relation to the IDEA. B(ii): Those implications are compared directly and develop a sustained argument across the works. Other valid comparative arrangements may achieve the same quality.",
          "nextStep": "Extend or refine only if a genuine contextual or analytical limitation remains; do not require a revision merely for its own sake.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 5/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "fictional-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 5/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        }
      },
      "teacherSource": "Scenario-specific constructed variation"
    },
    {
      "id": "character-arc-4",
      "number": 4,
      "label": "Different ACs: Text 2",
      "description": "Text 1 keeps the selected AC; Text 2 uses a different AC to develop the same IDEA as variation 1.",
      "idea": "Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships.",
      "aChoice": "Character arc",
      "bChoice": "Recurring imagery",
      "aGraph": [
        28,
        52,
        76
      ],
      "bGraph": [
        48,
        60,
        82
      ],
      "aMoments": [
        {
          "title": "News of her mother’s death",
          "evidence": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news.",
          "deconstruction": "Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother. This is one side of a comparison between different broader authorial choices."
        },
        {
          "title": "Sarah begins considering her own death",
          "evidence": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future.",
          "deconstruction": "The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality. The different ACs can now be related through their consequences for the same IDEA."
        },
        {
          "title": "Final inward fixation",
          "evidence": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose.",
          "deconstruction": "Her final condition demonstrates the personal consequences of unmanaged fear. The endpoint allows the consequences of both ACs to be compared without requiring matching techniques."
        }
      ],
      "bMoments": [
        {
          "title": "Signs of illness",
          "evidence": "Images of physical decline repeatedly draw Frank’s attention to death.",
          "deconstruction": "The recurring details reinforce his anxious attention to mortality. This is one side of a comparison between different broader authorial choices."
        },
        {
          "title": "Images of entrapment",
          "evidence": "Repeated references to confinement parallel his growing fear.",
          "deconstruction": "Magnet links fear of death to a narrowing range of responses. The different ACs can now be related through their consequences for the same IDEA."
        },
        {
          "title": "Labyrinth",
          "evidence": "The final repeated imagery of blocked routes leaves Frank unable to escape.",
          "deconstruction": "The recurrence connects his fixation with his inability to move forward. The endpoint allows the consequences of both ACs to be compared without requiring matching techniques."
        }
      ],
      "exemplar": "Cup constructs Sarah’s character arc through her movement from indifference about her mother’s death to anxiety about her own, whereas Magnet develops the related IDEA through recurring imagery surrounding Frank. As Sarah begins considering her mortality, her earlier disregard becomes significant: the death she could avoid when it concerned her mother demands attention when she imagines it happening to herself. Magnet repeatedly uses physical decline and images of confinement around Frank, so his fear appears in the details that accompany his experiences. Cup makes an encounter with physical decay alter Sarah’s earlier indifference, whereas Magnet follows the narrowing effects of Frank’s anxiety through the recurrence of images of threat. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother, while the recurring details reinforce his anxious attention to mortality. Sarah’s final preoccupation and Frank’s continued association with images of blocked movement both show how fear reduces their attention to life beyond death. The final pairing therefore concerns the restrictions the characters place on themselves, though the authors construct those restrictions through different choices. Comparing the arc in The Pen with the recurring images in The Water Bottle explains how different authorial choices can reveal the same damage to a character’s relationships and sense of purpose. The contrast is sustained through the final episodes: Cup’s changing character response and Magnet’s recurring imagery both make withdrawal visible, although they attribute that withdrawal to different developments.",
      "originalFive": "Cup constructs Sarah’s character arc through her movement from indifference about her mother’s death to anxiety about her own, whereas Magnet develops the related IDEA through recurring imagery surrounding Frank. As Sarah begins considering her mortality, her earlier disregard becomes significant: the death she could avoid when it concerned her mother demands attention when she imagines it happening to herself. Magnet repeatedly uses physical decline and images of confinement around Frank, so his fear appears in the details that accompany his experiences. Cup makes an encounter with physical decay alter Sarah’s earlier indifference, whereas Magnet follows the narrowing effects of Frank’s anxiety through the recurrence of images of threat. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother, while the recurring details reinforce his anxious attention to mortality. Sarah’s final preoccupation and Frank’s continued association with images of blocked movement both show how fear reduces their attention to life beyond death. The final pairing therefore concerns the restrictions the characters place on themselves, though the authors construct those restrictions through different choices. Comparing the arc in The Pen with the recurring images in The Water Bottle explains how different authorial choices can reveal the same damage to a character’s relationships and sense of purpose. The contrast is sustained through the final episodes: Cup’s changing character response and Magnet’s recurring imagery both make withdrawal visible, although they attribute that withdrawal to different developments.",
      "bands": {
        "1": {
          "level": 1,
          "label": "Basic identification with little analysis or comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Donald Cup uses character arc in The Pen. Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. This is a later development for the character, who now responds differently from before. It is part of what happens to the character over time.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. The final description shows the character at the end of the work. It follows the earlier developments and concludes the character’s experience.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Marge Magnet uses recurring imagery in The Water Bottle.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Images of physical decline repeatedly draw Frank’s attention to death. The author introduces another character in a situation involving death. The story begins by showing the character’s reaction to the news.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Repeated references to confinement parallel his growing fear. This is a further stage in the character’s story, after the original event. The reader sees how the situation continues to change.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "The final repeated imagery of blocked routes leaves Frank unable to escape. The last scene describes what the character is thinking about near the end. It comes after the other events in the character’s story.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The Pen and The Water Bottle both deal with a related subject. The events in the two works are different, but in both cases the writers return to it throughout the stories.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup uses character arc in The Pen. Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships. Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. This is a later development for the character, who now responds differently from before. It is part of what happens to the character over time. Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. The final description shows the character at the end of the work. It follows the earlier developments and concludes the character’s experience. Marge Magnet uses recurring imagery in The Water Bottle. Images of physical decline repeatedly draw Frank’s attention to death. The author introduces another character in a situation involving death. The story begins by showing the character’s reaction to the news. Repeated references to confinement parallel his growing fear. This is a further stage in the character’s story, after the original event. The reader sees how the situation continues to change. The final repeated imagery of blocked routes leaves Frank unable to escape. The last scene describes what the character is thinking about near the end. It comes after the other events in the character’s story. The Pen and The Water Bottle both deal with a related subject. The events in the two works are different, but in both cases the writers return to it throughout the stories.",
          "why": "B(i): The writing chiefly recounts or identifies moments. It offers very limited explanation of how authorial choices construct meaning. B(ii): The works are discussed separately, and any relationship is only a broad observation.",
          "nextStep": "Deconstruct one precise detail in each work before explaining the significance of their relationship.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 1/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 1/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "2": {
          "level": 2,
          "label": "Simple effects and surface comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both explore a similar concern in The Pen and The Water Bottle. Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. This shows the character’s reaction to the event. This is introduced near the beginning.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Images of physical decline repeatedly draw Frank’s attention to death.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The opening moments involve News of her mother’s death and Signs of illness. They are different, but both introduce the subject of the two works.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The reaction changes during the story. This follows the earlier situation.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Repeated references to confinement parallel his growing fear. The reaction changes during the story. The events develop further after this point.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The two later moments also concern the same issue. The authors choose different events, and both move their stories on from the beginning.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "The final repeated imagery of blocked routes leaves Frank unable to escape.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "These endings are alike because they both return to the central concern. The descriptions and situations are different in each text.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The choices in The Pen and The Water Bottle are similar in a general way because both writers address this issue. Each story has moments at the beginning, middle and end that deal with it.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both explore a similar concern in The Pen and The Water Bottle. Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships. Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. This shows the character’s reaction to the event. This is introduced near the beginning. Images of physical decline repeatedly draw Frank’s attention to death. The opening moments involve News of her mother’s death and Signs of illness. They are different, but both introduce the subject of the two works. Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The reaction changes during the story. This follows the earlier situation. Repeated references to confinement parallel his growing fear. The reaction changes during the story. The events develop further after this point. The two later moments also concern the same issue. The authors choose different events, and both move their stories on from the beginning. Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. The final repeated imagery of blocked routes leaves Frank unable to escape. These endings are alike because they both return to the central concern. The descriptions and situations are different in each text. The choices in The Pen and The Water Bottle are similar in a general way because both writers address this issue. Each story has moments at the beginning, middle and end that deal with it.",
          "why": "B(i): Some choices and effects are recognised, but explanations remain broad or asserted. B(ii): Obvious similarities and differences are identified without explaining why the contrasting constructions matter.",
          "nextStep": "Explain what a specific detail connotes in each work, then compare those implications.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 2/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 2/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "3": {
          "level": 3,
          "label": "Some deconstruction and relevant comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet develop a related concern across The Pen and The Water Bottle. Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Images of physical decline repeatedly draw Frank’s attention to death. The recurring details reinforce his anxious attention to mortality.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The first moments establish a related concern, but the initial situations are different. This contrast gives the two works different starting points for the same topic.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Repeated references to confinement parallel his growing fear. Magnet links fear of death to a narrowing range of responses.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The later events continue the concern in both works.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. This concluding detail returns to the problem developed earlier in the work.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "The final repeated imagery of blocked routes leaves Frank unable to escape. The final scene or image similarly returns attention to that problem.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The final moments return to the concern raised earlier, and both give further evidence of its importance. The endings can be connected to each other at the level of the characters’ or situations’ outcomes.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Together, these moments show a developing relationship between the works.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet develop a related concern across The Pen and The Water Bottle. Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships. Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother. Images of physical decline repeatedly draw Frank’s attention to death. The recurring details reinforce his anxious attention to mortality. The first moments establish a related concern, but the initial situations are different. This contrast gives the two works different starting points for the same topic. Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality. Repeated references to confinement parallel his growing fear. Magnet links fear of death to a narrowing range of responses. The later events continue the concern in both works. Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. This concluding detail returns to the problem developed earlier in the work. The final repeated imagery of blocked routes leaves Frank unable to escape. The final scene or image similarly returns attention to that problem. The final moments return to the concern raised earlier, and both give further evidence of its importance. The endings can be connected to each other at the level of the characters’ or situations’ outcomes. Together, these moments show a developing relationship between the works.",
          "why": "B(i): Some individual moments are meaningfully deconstructed, though the analytical precision and coverage are uneven. B(ii): Relevant comparisons begin to explain the shared IDEA, but important relationships remain descriptive or underdeveloped.",
          "nextStep": "Deepen an insufficiently analysed moment and use its specific implication to strengthen a direct comparison.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 3/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 3/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "4": {
          "level": 4,
          "label": "Developed analysis and comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both examine the idea that fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships, constructing distinct developments across their works.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Images of physical decline repeatedly draw Frank’s attention to death. The recurring details reinforce his anxious attention to mortality.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The contrast between news of her mother’s death and signs of illness establishes distinct starting points for the comparison.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Repeated references to confinement parallel his growing fear. Magnet links fear of death to a narrowing range of responses.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The middle pair qualifies those openings, showing how the choices continue to affect what the characters understand and whether their responses become more restrictive.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. Her final condition demonstrates the personal consequences of unmanaged fear.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "The final repeated imagery of blocked routes leaves Frank unable to escape. The recurrence connects his fixation with his inability to move forward.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The outcomes bring the shared IDEA into focus, and each ending gains meaning from the earlier moments; the comparison still needs to explain more precisely why the final authorial decisions differ.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both examine the idea that fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships, constructing distinct developments across their works. Sarah shows little interest and cannot recall when she heard the news. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother. Images of physical decline repeatedly draw Frank’s attention to death. The recurring details reinforce his anxious attention to mortality. The contrast between news of her mother’s death and signs of illness establishes distinct starting points for the comparison. Her attention moves from dismissal of someone else’s death to anxiety about her future. The change suggests that avoidance did not resolve her fear of mortality. Repeated references to confinement parallel his growing fear. Magnet links fear of death to a narrowing range of responses. The middle pair qualifies those openings, showing how the choices continue to affect what the characters understand and whether their responses become more restrictive. Sarah becomes preoccupied with what will happen to her and struggles to maintain a sense of purpose. Her final condition demonstrates the personal consequences of unmanaged fear. The final repeated imagery of blocked routes leaves Frank unable to escape. The recurrence connects his fixation with his inability to move forward. The outcomes bring the shared IDEA into focus, and each ending gains meaning from the earlier moments; the comparison still needs to explain more precisely why the final authorial decisions differ.",
          "why": "B(i): Most selected moments receive relevant, specific deconstruction, although not every implication is equally developed. B(ii): The work makes substantive comparisons across the wider construction, with occasional loss of precision or sustained synthesis.",
          "nextStep": "Refine the least fully explained paired moment and its relationship to the governing IDEA.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 4/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 4/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "5": {
          "level": 5,
          "label": "Sustained comparative deconstruction",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Cup constructs Sarah’s character arc through her movement from indifference about her mother’s death to anxiety about her own, whereas Magnet develops the related IDEA through recurring imagery surrounding Frank.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "whereas",
                  "kind": "idea"
                },
                {
                  "text": "character arc",
                  "kind": "ac"
                },
                {
                  "text": "recurring imagery",
                  "kind": "ac"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "As Sarah begins considering her mortality, her earlier disregard becomes significant: the death she could avoid when it concerned her mother demands attention when she imagines it happening to herself.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Magnet repeatedly uses physical decline and images of confinement around Frank, so his fear appears in the details that accompany his experiences.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Cup makes an encounter with physical decay alter Sarah’s earlier indifference, whereas Magnet follows the narrowing effects of Frank’s anxiety through the recurrence of images of threat.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "whereas",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother, while the recurring details reinforce his anxious attention to mortality.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "while",
                  "kind": "idea"
                },
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Sarah’s final preoccupation and Frank’s continued association with images of blocked movement both show how fear reduces their attention to life beyond death.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The final pairing therefore concerns the restrictions the characters place on themselves, though the authors construct those restrictions through different choices.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Comparing the arc in The Pen with the recurring images in The Water Bottle explains how different authorial choices can reveal the same damage to a character’s relationships and sense of purpose.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The contrast is sustained through the final episodes: Cup’s changing character response and Magnet’s recurring imagery both make withdrawal visible, although they attribute that withdrawal to different developments.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "although",
                  "kind": "idea"
                },
                {
                  "text": "recurring imagery",
                  "kind": "ac"
                }
              ]
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Cup constructs Sarah’s character arc through her movement from indifference about her mother’s death to anxiety about her own, whereas Magnet develops the related IDEA through recurring imagery surrounding Frank. As Sarah begins considering her mortality, her earlier disregard becomes significant: the death she could avoid when it concerned her mother demands attention when she imagines it happening to herself. Magnet repeatedly uses physical decline and images of confinement around Frank, so his fear appears in the details that accompany his experiences. Cup makes an encounter with physical decay alter Sarah’s earlier indifference, whereas Magnet follows the narrowing effects of Frank’s anxiety through the recurrence of images of threat. Cup establishes how habitual avoidance has damaged Sarah’s engagement with her mother, while the recurring details reinforce his anxious attention to mortality. Sarah’s final preoccupation and Frank’s continued association with images of blocked movement both show how fear reduces their attention to life beyond death. The final pairing therefore concerns the restrictions the characters place on themselves, though the authors construct those restrictions through different choices. Comparing the arc in The Pen with the recurring images in The Water Bottle explains how different authorial choices can reveal the same damage to a character’s relationships and sense of purpose. The contrast is sustained through the final episodes: Cup’s changing character response and Magnet’s recurring imagery both make withdrawal visible, although they attribute that withdrawal to different developments.",
          "why": "B(i): Specific details of the authorial constructions are consistently deconstructed in relation to the IDEA. B(ii): Those implications are compared directly and develop a sustained argument across the works. Other valid comparative arrangements may achieve the same quality.",
          "nextStep": "Extend or refine only if a genuine contextual or analytical limitation remains; do not require a revision merely for its own sake.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 5/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "fictional-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 5/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        }
      },
      "teacherSource": "Scenario-specific constructed variation"
    },
    {
      "id": "character-arc-5",
      "number": 5,
      "label": "Different ACs: Text 1",
      "description": "Text 2 keeps the selected AC; Text 1 uses a different AC to develop the same IDEA as variation 1.",
      "idea": "Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships.",
      "aChoice": "Setting",
      "bChoice": "Character arc",
      "aGraph": [
        64,
        42,
        79
      ],
      "bGraph": [
        22,
        45,
        77
      ],
      "aMoments": [
        {
          "title": "Mausoleum",
          "evidence": "Sarah enters a setting associated with physical death and her avoidance becomes difficult to sustain.",
          "deconstruction": "The place confronts her with the loss she has evaded. This work develops the IDEA through a different broader AC from its counterpart."
        },
        {
          "title": "Mother’s bedroom",
          "evidence": "Sarah revisits an intimate space associated with her mother.",
          "deconstruction": "The familiar room requires her to acknowledge the personal relationship behind the loss. The distinct construction offers an alternative explanation of the shared conceptual concern."
        },
        {
          "title": "Bedroom reinterpreted",
          "evidence": "A once painful setting allows a different emotional response.",
          "deconstruction": "Cup uses the change in setting to test whether acceptance can replace fear. The endpoint allows the two different ACs to be compared through their contribution to the IDEA."
        }
      ],
      "bMoments": [
        {
          "title": "News of his grandmother’s death",
          "evidence": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss.",
          "deconstruction": "Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. This work develops the IDEA through a different broader AC from its counterpart."
        },
        {
          "title": "Increasing preoccupation",
          "evidence": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him.",
          "deconstruction": "His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others. The distinct construction offers an alternative explanation of the shared conceptual concern."
        },
        {
          "title": "Final self-destructive fixation",
          "evidence": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction.",
          "deconstruction": "The similar ending links his fixation to Sarah’s different initial avoidance. The endpoint allows the two different ACs to be compared through their contribution to the IDEA."
        }
      ],
      "exemplar": "Cup uses settings in The Pen to examine Sarah’s avoidance of death, while Magnet follows Frank’s character arc in The Water Bottle. The mausoleum requires Sarah to confront physical decay after she has shown little interest in her mother’s death, whereas Frank begins his story already troubled by his grandmother’s death. Cup later returns Sarah to her mother’s bedroom, where the personal objects connect mortality with a relationship she had tried to disregard. Cup makes an encounter with physical decay alter Sarah’s earlier indifference, whereas Magnet follows the narrowing effects of Frank’s anxiety through the recurrence of images of threat. The place confronts her with the loss she has evaded, while Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. Magnet instead develops Frank’s fixation until it restricts his ability to engage with others. The final pairing therefore concerns the restrictions the characters place on themselves, though the authors construct those restrictions through different choices. Sarah’s changed response to the bedroom allows Cup to consider the possibility of accepting loss, while Frank’s continuing distress suggests the costs of remaining preoccupied with it. The setting and the character arc therefore provide different forms of evidence for the consequences of fearing death. The contrast is sustained through the final episodes: Cup’s changing character response and Magnet’s recurring imagery both make withdrawal visible, although they attribute that withdrawal to different developments.",
      "originalFive": "Cup uses settings in The Pen to examine Sarah’s avoidance of death, while Magnet follows Frank’s character arc in The Water Bottle. The mausoleum requires Sarah to confront physical decay after she has shown little interest in her mother’s death, whereas Frank begins his story already troubled by his grandmother’s death. Cup later returns Sarah to her mother’s bedroom, where the personal objects connect mortality with a relationship she had tried to disregard. Cup makes an encounter with physical decay alter Sarah’s earlier indifference, whereas Magnet follows the narrowing effects of Frank’s anxiety through the recurrence of images of threat. The place confronts her with the loss she has evaded, while Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. Magnet instead develops Frank’s fixation until it restricts his ability to engage with others. The final pairing therefore concerns the restrictions the characters place on themselves, though the authors construct those restrictions through different choices. Sarah’s changed response to the bedroom allows Cup to consider the possibility of accepting loss, while Frank’s continuing distress suggests the costs of remaining preoccupied with it. The setting and the character arc therefore provide different forms of evidence for the consequences of fearing death. The contrast is sustained through the final episodes: Cup’s changing character response and Magnet’s recurring imagery both make withdrawal visible, although they attribute that withdrawal to different developments.",
      "bands": {
        "1": {
          "level": 1,
          "label": "Basic identification with little analysis or comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Donald Cup uses setting in The Pen. Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah enters a setting associated with physical death and her avoidance becomes difficult to sustain.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah revisits an intimate space associated with her mother. This is a later development for the character, who now responds differently from before. It is part of what happens to the character over time.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "A once painful setting allows a different emotional response. The final description shows the character at the end of the work. It follows the earlier developments and concludes the character’s experience.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Marge Magnet uses character arc in The Water Bottle.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. The author introduces another character in a situation involving death. The story begins by showing the character’s reaction to the news.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. This is a further stage in the character’s story, after the original event. The reader sees how the situation continues to change.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The last scene describes what the character is thinking about near the end. It comes after the other events in the character’s story.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The Pen and The Water Bottle both deal with a related subject. The events in the two works are different, but in both cases the writers return to it throughout the stories.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup uses setting in The Pen. Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships. Sarah enters a setting associated with physical death and her avoidance becomes difficult to sustain. Sarah revisits an intimate space associated with her mother. This is a later development for the character, who now responds differently from before. It is part of what happens to the character over time. A once painful setting allows a different emotional response. The final description shows the character at the end of the work. It follows the earlier developments and concludes the character’s experience. Marge Magnet uses character arc in The Water Bottle. Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. The author introduces another character in a situation involving death. The story begins by showing the character’s reaction to the news. Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. This is a further stage in the character’s story, after the original event. The reader sees how the situation continues to change. Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The last scene describes what the character is thinking about near the end. It comes after the other events in the character’s story. The Pen and The Water Bottle both deal with a related subject. The events in the two works are different, but in both cases the writers return to it throughout the stories.",
          "why": "B(i): The writing chiefly recounts or identifies moments. It offers very limited explanation of how authorial choices construct meaning. B(ii): The works are discussed separately, and any relationship is only a broad observation.",
          "nextStep": "Deconstruct one precise detail in each work before explaining the significance of their relationship.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 1/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 1/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "2": {
          "level": 2,
          "label": "Simple effects and surface comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both explore a similar concern in The Pen and The Water Bottle. Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah enters a setting associated with physical death and her avoidance becomes difficult to sustain. This shows the character’s reaction to the event. This is introduced near the beginning.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The opening moments involve Mausoleum and News of his grandmother’s death. They are different, but both introduce the subject of the two works.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah revisits an intimate space associated with her mother. The reaction changes during the story. This follows the earlier situation.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. The reaction changes during the story. The events develop further after this point.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The two later moments also concern the same issue. The authors choose different events, and both move their stories on from the beginning.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "A once painful setting allows a different emotional response.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The ending continues to show the character’s feelings.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "These endings are alike because they both return to the central concern. The descriptions and situations are different in each text.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The choices in The Pen and The Water Bottle are similar in a general way because both writers address this issue. Each story has moments at the beginning, middle and end that deal with it.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both explore a similar concern in The Pen and The Water Bottle. Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships. Sarah enters a setting associated with physical death and her avoidance becomes difficult to sustain. This shows the character’s reaction to the event. This is introduced near the beginning. Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. The opening moments involve Mausoleum and News of his grandmother’s death. They are different, but both introduce the subject of the two works. Sarah revisits an intimate space associated with her mother. The reaction changes during the story. This follows the earlier situation. Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. The reaction changes during the story. The events develop further after this point. The two later moments also concern the same issue. The authors choose different events, and both move their stories on from the beginning. A once painful setting allows a different emotional response. Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The ending continues to show the character’s feelings. These endings are alike because they both return to the central concern. The descriptions and situations are different in each text. The choices in The Pen and The Water Bottle are similar in a general way because both writers address this issue. Each story has moments at the beginning, middle and end that deal with it.",
          "why": "B(i): Some choices and effects are recognised, but explanations remain broad or asserted. B(ii): Obvious similarities and differences are identified without explaining why the contrasting constructions matter.",
          "nextStep": "Explain what a specific detail connotes in each work, then compare those implications.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 2/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 2/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "3": {
          "level": 3,
          "label": "Some deconstruction and relevant comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet develop a related concern across The Pen and The Water Bottle. Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah enters a setting associated with physical death and her avoidance becomes difficult to sustain. The place confronts her with the loss she has evaded.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The first moments establish a related concern, but the initial situations are different. This contrast gives the two works different starting points for the same topic.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah revisits an intimate space associated with her mother. The familiar room requires her to acknowledge the personal relationship behind the loss.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The later events continue the concern in both works.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "A once painful setting allows a different emotional response. This concluding detail returns to the problem developed earlier in the work.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The final scene or image similarly returns attention to that problem.",
              "operation": "explain",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The final moments return to the concern raised earlier, and both give further evidence of its importance. The endings can be connected to each other at the level of the characters’ or situations’ outcomes.",
              "operation": "compare",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Together, these moments show a developing relationship between the works.",
              "operation": "identify",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet develop a related concern across The Pen and The Water Bottle. Fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships. Sarah enters a setting associated with physical death and her avoidance becomes difficult to sustain. The place confronts her with the loss she has evaded. Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. The first moments establish a related concern, but the initial situations are different. This contrast gives the two works different starting points for the same topic. Sarah revisits an intimate space associated with her mother. The familiar room requires her to acknowledge the personal relationship behind the loss. Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others. The later events continue the concern in both works. A once painful setting allows a different emotional response. This concluding detail returns to the problem developed earlier in the work. Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The final scene or image similarly returns attention to that problem. The final moments return to the concern raised earlier, and both give further evidence of its importance. The endings can be connected to each other at the level of the characters’ or situations’ outcomes. Together, these moments show a developing relationship between the works.",
          "why": "B(i): Some individual moments are meaningfully deconstructed, though the analytical precision and coverage are uneven. B(ii): Relevant comparisons begin to explain the shared IDEA, but important relationships remain descriptive or underdeveloped.",
          "nextStep": "Deepen an insufficiently analysed moment and use its specific implication to strengthen a direct comparison.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 3/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 3/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "4": {
          "level": 4,
          "label": "Developed analysis and comparison",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both examine the idea that fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships, constructing distinct developments across their works.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah enters a setting associated with physical death and her avoidance becomes difficult to sustain. The place confronts her with the loss she has evaded.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "setting",
                  "kind": "ac"
                },
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The contrast between mausoleum and news of his grandmother’s death establishes distinct starting points for the comparison.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Sarah revisits an intimate space associated with her mother. The familiar room requires her to acknowledge the personal relationship behind the loss.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The middle pair qualifies those openings, showing how the choices continue to affect what the characters understand and whether their responses become more restrictive.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "A once painful setting allows a different emotional response. Cup uses the change in setting to test whether acceptance can replace fear.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "setting",
                  "kind": "ac"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The similar ending links his fixation to Sarah’s different initial avoidance.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The outcomes bring the shared IDEA into focus, and each ending gains meaning from the earlier moments; the comparison still needs to explain more precisely why the final authorial decisions differ.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Donald Cup and Marge Magnet both examine the idea that fear of death can prevent individuals from maintaining meaningful relationships, constructing distinct developments across their works. Sarah enters a setting associated with physical death and her avoidance becomes difficult to sustain. The place confronts her with the loss she has evaded. Frank responds with persistent distress and fixates on his loss. Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. The contrast between mausoleum and news of his grandmother’s death establishes distinct starting points for the comparison. Sarah revisits an intimate space associated with her mother. The familiar room requires her to acknowledge the personal relationship behind the loss. Frank repeatedly returns to what death means for him. His grief develops into persistent anxiety and affects his engagement with others. The middle pair qualifies those openings, showing how the choices continue to affect what the characters understand and whether their responses become more restrictive. A once painful setting allows a different emotional response. Cup uses the change in setting to test whether acceptance can replace fear. Frank remains preoccupied with his own death and loses a sense of direction. The similar ending links his fixation to Sarah’s different initial avoidance. The outcomes bring the shared IDEA into focus, and each ending gains meaning from the earlier moments; the comparison still needs to explain more precisely why the final authorial decisions differ.",
          "why": "B(i): Most selected moments receive relevant, specific deconstruction, although not every implication is equally developed. B(ii): The work makes substantive comparisons across the wider construction, with occasional loss of precision or sustained synthesis.",
          "nextStep": "Refine the least fully explained paired moment and its relationship to the governing IDEA.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 4/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "constructed-paired-skills-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 4/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        },
        "5": {
          "level": 5,
          "label": "Sustained comparative deconstruction",
          "sentences": [
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Cup uses settings in The Pen to examine Sarah’s avoidance of death, while Magnet follows Frank’s character arc in The Water Bottle.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "while",
                  "kind": "idea"
                },
                {
                  "text": "setting",
                  "kind": "ac"
                },
                {
                  "text": "character arc",
                  "kind": "ac"
                },
                {
                  "text": "void",
                  "kind": "specific"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The mausoleum requires Sarah to confront physical decay after she has shown little interest in her mother’s death, whereas Frank begins his story already troubled by his grandmother’s death.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "whereas",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "red",
              "text": "Cup later returns Sarah to her mother’s bedroom, where the personal objects connect mortality with a relationship she had tried to disregard.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Cup makes an encounter with physical decay alter Sarah’s earlier indifference, whereas Magnet follows the narrowing effects of Frank’s anxiety through the recurrence of images of threat.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "whereas",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The place confronts her with the loss she has evaded, while Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "while",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "blue",
              "text": "Magnet instead develops Frank’s fixation until it restricts his ability to engage with others.",
              "operation": "deconstruct",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The final pairing therefore concerns the restrictions the characters place on themselves, though the authors construct those restrictions through different choices.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": []
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "Sarah’s changed response to the bedroom allows Cup to consider the possibility of accepting loss, while Frank’s continuing distress suggests the costs of remaining preoccupied with it.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "while",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The setting and the character arc therefore provide different forms of evidence for the consequences of fearing death.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "setting",
                  "kind": "ac"
                },
                {
                  "text": "character arc",
                  "kind": "ac"
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "role": "purple",
              "text": "The contrast is sustained through the final episodes: Cup’s changing character response and Magnet’s recurring imagery both make withdrawal visible, although they attribute that withdrawal to different developments.",
              "operation": "compare-meaning",
              "marks": [
                {
                  "text": "although",
                  "kind": "idea"
                }
              ]
            }
          ],
          "paragraph": "Cup uses settings in The Pen to examine Sarah’s avoidance of death, while Magnet follows Frank’s character arc in The Water Bottle. The mausoleum requires Sarah to confront physical decay after she has shown little interest in her mother’s death, whereas Frank begins his story already troubled by his grandmother’s death. Cup later returns Sarah to her mother’s bedroom, where the personal objects connect mortality with a relationship she had tried to disregard. Cup makes an encounter with physical decay alter Sarah’s earlier indifference, whereas Magnet follows the narrowing effects of Frank’s anxiety through the recurrence of images of threat. The place confronts her with the loss she has evaded, while Magnet establishes a more immediate and overt response to death. Magnet instead develops Frank’s fixation until it restricts his ability to engage with others. The final pairing therefore concerns the restrictions the characters place on themselves, though the authors construct those restrictions through different choices. Sarah’s changed response to the bedroom allows Cup to consider the possibility of accepting loss, while Frank’s continuing distress suggests the costs of remaining preoccupied with it. The setting and the character arc therefore provide different forms of evidence for the consequences of fearing death. The contrast is sustained through the final episodes: Cup’s changing character response and Magnet’s recurring imagery both make withdrawal visible, although they attribute that withdrawal to different developments.",
          "why": "B(i): Specific details of the authorial constructions are consistently deconstructed in relation to the IDEA. B(ii): Those implications are compared directly and develop a sustained argument across the works. Other valid comparative arrangements may achieve the same quality.",
          "nextStep": "Extend or refine only if a genuine contextual or analytical limitation remains; do not require a revision merely for its own sake.",
          "singleWorkProfile": "In this exercise B(i) and B(ii) are deliberately paired at 5/5. Outside this exercise they are judged independently.",
          "sourceType": "fictional-teaching-model",
          "calibration": "Demonstration models intentionally pair B(i) and B(ii) at the same teaching level; real Paper 2 assessment can produce different B(i)/B(ii) levels for one response.",
          "practiceCaveat": "Teaching model: this 5/5 demonstrates a similar standard in B(i) and B(ii) for this exercise only. In actual Paper 2, these may differ (e.g., B(i) 4/5 and B(ii) 1/5). These are illustrative levels, not IB marks."
        }
      },
      "teacherSource": "Scenario-specific constructed variation"
    }
  ]
}
